EPO logo
EPO boards of appeal decisions
homepage => search & index => boards of appeal decisions
Search mask List of updates
Date of decision 27 November 2003
Case number T 0172/03 - 3.5.1
Application number 96115736.9
IPC G06F17/60
Proceedings Language EN
Title of the application Order management system and method considering budget limit
Applicant name Ricoh Company, Ltd.
Opponent name -
Headnote
-
Articles and Rules EPC . Art 52(1)
. Art 56
. Art 54
Keywords
Inventive step (no)
Cited Decisions T 0769/92
T 0931/95
T 0967/97
T 0049/99
T 0641/00
Catchwords:
1. The term "state of the art" in Article 54 EPC should, in compliance with the French and German text, be understood as "state of technology", which in the context of the EPC does not include the state of the art in commerce and business methods. The term "everything" in Article 54(2) EPC is to be understood as concerning such kind of information which is relevant to some field of technology.

2. From these considerations it follows that anything which is not related to any technological field or field from which, because of its informational character, a skilled person would expect to derive any technically relevant information, does not belong to the state of the art to be considered in the context of Articles 54 and 56, even if it had been made available to the general public before the relevant priority date (see points 8 to 10 of the reasons).


get the full pdf
 

EPO Home Page | Recent updates | Request info | Send comments | Index
Patent information on the internet

Copyright © 1997-2004 European Patent Office . All Rights Reserved.
E-mail: EPO Mail Distribution