EPO logo
EPO boards of appeal decisions
homepage => search & index => boards of appeal decisions
Search mask List of updates
Date of decision 25 April 2007
Case number T 0211/06 - 3.3.07
Application number 01982798.9
IPC B01J37/02
Proceedings Language EN
Title of the application Processing method utilizing display information and cell structure processed by the processing method
Applicant name NGK INSULATORS, LTD.
Opponent name -
Headnote
-
Articles and Rules EPC . Art 54(2)
. Art 56
. Art 111(1)
. R 27
PCT . R 5
Keywords
Internal art and subjective
laboratory practice
- not prior art under Article 54(2) EPC, and not a possible correct starting point for assessing inventive step
Cited Decisions T 0248/85
T 0654/92
T 0691/94
Catchwords:
Disclosure in the application as filed which turns out on the available evidence not to be prior art under Article 54(2) EPC cannot be used as starting point for assessing inventive step nor can subjective "laboratory practice" put forward by the examining division without any objective evidence that this was knowledge available to the public be used as a starting point for assessing inventive step.

get the full pdf
 

EPO Home Page | Recent updates | Request info | Send comments | Index
Patent information on the internet

Copyright © 1997-2006 European Patent Office . All Rights Reserved.
E-mail: EPO Mail Distribution