EPO logo
EPO boards of appeal decisions
homepage => search & index => boards of appeal decisions
Search mask List of updates
Date of decision 21 October 1999
Case number T 0904/97 - 3.4.2
Application number 93110200.8
IPC G03G15/00
Proceedings Language EN
Title of the application Apparatus for forming an image on a record medium
Applicant name Seiko Epson Corporation
Opponent name Canon Inc.
Headnote
-
Articles and Rules EPC . Art 76(1)
. Art 100(a)
. Art 100(c)
. Art 54
. Art 56
. R 25
Keywords
Division of a divisional application
Benefit of the filing date of the grandparent application (no)
Patentability (no)
Cited Decisions T 0905/97
T 0906/97
T 0206/93
T 0194/84
T 0434/97
Catchwords:
1. Since both the divisional application for which the patent in suit is granted and the parent application comprise subject-matter extending beyond the content of the grandparent application as originally filed, the second-generation patent cannot possibly benefit from the filing date of the grandparent application, the publication of which therefore belongs to the prior art under Article 54(2) EPC.

2. Thus there was no need for the Board in the present circumstances to further investigate the issues of the admissibility of sequences of divisional applications and of their proper handling, which therefore could be left open (point 2 of the Reasons).


get the full pdf
 

EPO Home Page | Recent updates | Request info | Send comments | Index
Patent information on the internet


Copyright © 1997-2000 European Patent Office . All Rights Reserved.
E-mail: EPO Mail Distribution