| T 0556/03 - 3.3.10 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
 |
T 0556/03
3.3.10 |
15 Februar 2008 |
01118017.1 |
Verfahren zur nicht oxidativen Herstellung von Formaldehyd aus Methanol |
C07C 45/00
|
| |
Keywords
Änderungen (zulässig) - sowohl in der vorliegenden Teilanmeldung als auch in der Stammanmeldung offenbart
Zurückverweisung |
| T 0936/03 - 3.3.08 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0936/03
3.3.08 |
21 June 2007 |
92307258.1 |
Crystalline lactulose trihydrate and a method for its manufacture |
C07H 3/04
|
| |
Keywords
Sufficiency of disclosure (yes)
Remittal to the opposition division (yes) |
| T 1042/03 - 3.5.04 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 1042/03
3.5.04 |
13 February 2008 |
98102571.1 |
Image data encoding system and image inputting apparatus |
G06T 11/00
|
| |
Keywords
Inventive step (no) |
| T 1232/03 - 3.3.01 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 1232/03
3.3.01 |
14 September 2006 |
98911812.0 |
Method of improving anti-shudder durability of power transmission fluids |
C10M 163/00
|
| |
Keywords
Lack of novelty objection due to prior use submitted with the statement of grounds of appeal: late filed (yes) — not admitted into the appeal proceedings as not prima facie relevant.
Technical report submitted after the statement of grounds of appeal by the Appellant: late filed (yes) - not admitted into the appeal proceedings as not prima facie relevant.
Technical reports submitted by the Appellant one month before the oral proceedings: late filed (yes) - not admitted into the proceedings - no opportunity for the Respondent to take position.
Main request, first and second auxiliary requests: inventive step (no) - no improvement within the whole claimed area — obvious alternative.
Third auxiliary request: inventive step (no) - alleged effect not credibly achieved for all claimed alternatives — extent of the claimed monopoly not justified by the technical contribution to the art.
Fourth auxiliary request: inventive step (yes) - non obvious alternative. |
| T 0260/04 - 3.3.07 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0260/04
3.3.07 |
07/2008.02.18 November 2007 |
00114815.4 |
Volumengebendes Haarbehandlungsmittel |
A61K 7/06
|
| |
Keywords
Hauptantrag - Neuheit (bejaht); erfinderische Tätigkeit (verneint)
Hilfsantrag 1 bis 3 - Änderungen nicht zulässig
Hilfsantrag 4 - Änderungen - zulässig; Berichtigung von Fehlern in der Entscheidung - zulässig
Erfinderische Tätigkeit (bejaht) - Aufgabe und Lösung |
| T 0451/04 - 3.4.01 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0451/04
3.4.01 |
18 December 2007 |
99939993.4 |
System for the transmission of data from a data carrier to a station by means of at least one other auxiliary carrier signal |
G06K 7/00
|
| |
Keywords
Novelty (yes: all requests)
Inventive step (no: main request and first auxiliary request; yes: fourth auxiliary request)
Clarity (no: second auxiliary request)
Admissibility of late-filed requests (no: third auxiliary request; yes: fourth auxiliary request) |
| T 0776/04 - 3.4.01 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0776/04
3.4.01 |
07 December 2007 |
01310535.8 |
Autonomous calibration of a wireless-global positioning system |
G01S 5/02
|
| |
Keywords
Novelty - (yes)
Inventive step - all requests (no) |
| T 0857/04 - 3.3.02 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0857/04
3.3.02 |
06 November 2007 |
94120045.3 |
Verwendung von R-(+)alpha-Liponsäure, R(-)-Dihydroliponsäure und Metabolite zur Behandlung von Diabetes mellitus sowie seiner Folgeerkrankungen |
A61K 31/385
|
| |
Keywords
Hauptantrag, Hilfsantrag 1: erfinderische Tätigkeit (verneint), erhöhte Wirkung der Enantiomere gegenüber den Razematen nahegelegt
Hilfsantrag 2: nicht zulässig, da verspätet eingereicht, keine Antwort auf neu vorgebrachte Tatsachen und Argumente |
| T 0916/04 - 3.3.06 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0916/04
3.3.06 |
11 January 2008 |
96108696.4 |
Oxygen production by ion transport membranes with work recovery |
B01D 53/22
|
| |
Keywords
Inventive step (no): all requests |
| T 1413/04 - 3.3.01 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 1413/04
3.3.01 |
29 Januar 2008 |
97909370.5 |
Festes Pflanzenschutzmittel |
A01N 25/14
|
| |
Keywords
Erfinderische Tätigkeit - (nein) - naheliegende Alternative |
| T 1437/04 - 3.3.09 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 1437/04
3.3.09 |
20 September 2007 |
98928177.9 |
A hydrophilic coating and a method for the preparation thereof |
C08J 7/04
|
| |
Keywords
Main request, Auxiliary Request 1, Amended Auxiliary Request 2, Auxiliary Request 5 - Novelty (no)
Auxiliary Request 3, Amended Auxiliary Request 4 - Clarity (no)
Amended Auxiliary Request 6 - Novelty (yes); Inventive step of Claim 7 (no)
Auxiliary Request 7 - Admissibility (no)
Auxiliary Request 8 - Novelty (yes); Inventive step (yes) |
| T 0012/05 - 3.3.08 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0012/05
3.3.08 |
30 06 2006 |
98124039.3 |
Nouvelles lignées cellulaires de complémentation pour vecteurs adénoviraux défectifs |
C12N 5/16
|
| |
Keywords
Requête principale : extension du contenu de la demande initiale (non)
Extension de la protection (non)
Matière ajoutée (non)
Clarté et support dans la description (oui)
Suffisance de description (oui)
Activité inventive (oui) |
| T 0253/05 - 3.3.06 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0253/05
3.3.06 |
25 September 2006 |
95905359.6 |
Detergent compositions containing percarbonate and amylase |
C11D 3/386
|
| |
Keywords
Added subject-matter (no)
Inventive step (yes): synergistic effect convincingly proved - prior art not suggesting the selection of the features of claim 1 for obtaining the seeked improvement |
| T 0316/05 - 3.3.10 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0316/05
3.3.10 |
19 December 2007 |
00978793.8 |
Method for oxidation of xylene derivatives |
C07C 51/265
|
| |
Keywords
Decision reasoned in the sense of Rule 111(2) [Rule 68(2)] EPC (no) - fresh feature - no decision on original disclosure - findings on substantive issues based on that feature - deficient reasoning
Substantial procedural violation (yes)
Reimbursement of appeal fee (yes)
Remittal to the first instance for further prosecution |
| T 0329/05 - 3.4.01 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0329/05
3.4.01 |
13 Dezember 2007 |
00912337.3 |
Empfangseinrichtung einer Radareinrichtung und Radareinrichtung |
G01S 7/35
|
| |
Keywords
Erfinderische Tätigkeit (ja) |
| T 0405/05 - 3.3.10 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0405/05
3.3.10 |
10 December 2007 |
95919208.9 |
Application of omega-hydrofluoroalkyl ethers |
C07C 43/12
|
| |
Keywords
Main request and auxiliary requests 1 to 3: Amendments (not allowable) - combination of features not originally disclosed
Auxiliary request 4: Amendment (not allowable) - reformatio in peius |
| T 0503/05 - 3.4.01 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0503/05
3.4.01 |
08 Januar 2008 |
02023745.9 |
Prüfung von Bildaufnahmen von Personen |
G06K 9/00
|
| |
Keywords
Neuheit - ja
Erfinderische Tätigkeit - ja |
| T 0561/05 - 3.3.03 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0561/05
3.3.03 |
05 December 2007 |
97925966.0 |
Process for rigid polyurethane foams |
C08G 18/50
|
| |
Keywords
Novelty - (yes)
Amendments - added subject-matter - (no)
Ground not substantiated in Statement of Grounds of Appeal |
| T 0592/05 - 3.4.02 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0592/05
3.4.02 |
14 February 2008 |
02445049.6 |
Device and method for optical inspection |
G01N 21/88
|
| |
Keywords
Inventive step - claim 1, 13 (yes) |
| T 0625/05 - 3.2.03 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0625/05
3.2.03 |
30 November 2007 |
99104333.2 |
Vorrichtung zum Abstützen von Fenster- oder Türrahmen an der Begrenzung einer Wandöffnung |
E06B 1/60
|
| |
Keywords
Neuheit (bejaht)
Erfinderische Tätigkeit nach Änderung (bejaht) |
| T 0645/05 - 3.3.01 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0645/05
3.3.01 |
10 Januar 2008 |
97108625.1 |
Bindemittel für emissionsarme Beschichtungsmassen |
C09D 133/00
|
| |
Keywords
Unzulässige Änderung (nein)
Ausreichende Offenbarung (ja)
Neuheit (ja)
Erfinderische Tätigkeit (ja) - aufgrund von Vergleichsversuchen |
| T 0746/05 - 3.4.02 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0746/05
3.4.02 |
25 February 2008 |
01100364.7 |
Flow cell with an inner layer of an amorphous fluoropolymer having a refractive index less than the refractive index of water |
G01N 21/05
|
| |
Keywords
Inventive step (yes) |
| T 0774/05 - 3.2.07 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0774/05
3.2.07 |
08 November 2007 |
95116064.7 |
Slicing machine for slicing two or more food loaves |
B26D 1/00
|
| |
Keywords
Admissibility of oppositions - yes (points 1 and 2)
Admissibility of appeal I - yes (point 3)
Admissibility of appeal II - no (point 4)
Request for accompanying person to present parts of the case - refused (point 5)
Late request to derogate from language of proceedings - allowed (point 6)
Interpretation from that language into the language of the proceedings - not allowed (point 6)
Late filed documents - admitted (point 7)
Admissibility of ground of novelty for one appellant - yes (point 8)
Novelty (patent as granted) - no (point 10)
Remittal - yes (point 11)
Request to refer questions to Enlarged Board of Appeal - refused (point 12) |
| T 0795/05 - 3.3.03 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0795/05
3.3.03 |
13 December 2007 |
95924038.3 |
Polymerization catalyst systems, their production and use |
C08F 10/00
|
| |
Keywords
Main request, first-seventh, ninth auxiliary requests: - added subject-matter - yes
Fourth, fifth, sixth, eighth, ninth auxiliary requests - amendments - extension beyond patent as granted - yes
Sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth auxiliary requests - claims - clarity - no |
| T 0843/05 - 3.2.03 |
| PDF |
Case number |
Date |
Application number |
Title |
IPC |
| |
T 0843/05
3.2.03 |
28 01 2008 |
00936978.6 |
Dispositif d'ancrage d'un câble de structure |
E04C 5/12
E01D 19/16
|
| |
Keywords
Activité inventive: oui |
